What American Idol Can Teach Us About Social Media

by Andrew Hanelly on May 26, 2010

american idol social media

Let’s be honest, I’m going to lose some friends for writing this. And I’m not just talking about Facebook friends. I’m talking about real, couch-moving, bail-paying, wedding-attending friends.

Well, I’m not planning on moving, getting arrested, or getting married anytime soon, so here is my confession:

I love American Idol. I’ve been a closet fan for years. In my head, Simon Cowell and I are old buddies. And now that it is (maybe) in it’s last season, I felt I needed to come forward.

But at least I can guise it as somewhat related to my profession:

American Idol is just like social media. Here’s what it has taught me:

Many will try, few will win. A lot of people try to get noticed, but only a handful really get everyone’s attention.

Once you’re on stage, be prepared for anything. This includes taunts, mockery, and below-the-belt insults. Develop thick skin – you’ll need it to survive.

You’re always being judged. You can’t mail in your performance. Everything is recorded, referred to, and scrutinized on replay. Make every word count.

There are a million other channels. No one has to subject themselves to you. They can easily flip the switch and find something else. Give them reasons to never do that.

What the crowd says, goes. You don’t have to be the most talented, the most technically proficient, or even the most original. If you’re likable, you stand a chance.

You don’t have to win to be successful. Some of the biggest success stories will come from those who never make it to the top – but they were noticed along the way.

Harsh criticism can be a blessing in disguise. But only if you embrace it, adapt your approach, learn and move on.

Did I miss any? Did you even make it this far?

If you liked this, try:

  1. How to Avoid Trolls, Landmines, and Time-Sucks in Social Media
  2. Don’t Hold Your Breath Waiting for A Social Media Parade in Your Honor
  3. Social Media Metrics Beyond Feel-Good Moments
  4. Likely Story: 5 Benefits of Being Well-Liked on Social Media
  5. Sweaty Armpits and Social Media Authenticity
Andrew Hanelly

post written by:

Andrew is Director of Digital Strategy for TMG and for one semester in college, was a sociology major. Follow him on Twitter.

Subscribe to feed via RSS or FOLLOW US ON TWITTER to connect.

Or, subscribe to Engage the Newsletter

* And oh yeah, these opinions belong to Andrew, not TMG Custom Media

{ 5 comments… read them below or add one }

Krissy May 26, 2010 at 10:25 am

Thanks for a great article… aside from my love of American Idol, I really think you’ve drawn good parallels here – the reason the show has been such a success (quality content, good buzz, etc.) are the same things to strive for in social strategy.

Reply

Jillian May 26, 2010 at 10:43 am

Hey, as far as guilty pleasure T.V. shows go, American Idol isn’t too bad! It could be tool academy….

Reply

Andrew Hanelly Andrew Hanelly May 28, 2010 at 1:13 pm

@Krissy: You hit the nail on the head and used way less words! Thanks for the comment.

@Jillian: Tool Academy can teach us a lot, too, mostly about making bad decisions though!

Reply

bill May 28, 2010 at 1:33 pm

Sad but true.

Reply

gerald watkins May 30, 2010 at 1:18 am

Keep thinking like that,and you will go far in this world.

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: